Carmel, Indiana, has become a hidden gem for pizza lovers, offering a variety of eateries where you can savor everything from classic pies to creative, gourmet creations.

Whether you prefer a traditional Margherita, a loaded deep dish, or a quirky topping combination, Carmel’s pizza parlors have something to delight every palate. With a mix of family-owned favorites and innovative newcomers, the city has crafted a thriving pizza scene that’s perfect for casual bites or special celebrations.

Join Crossroads Foundation Repair as we explore the six best pizza spots in Carmel, where the crust is always just right, the cheese is perfectly melted, and the toppings are second to none!

1. Roselli’s Pizza

With a cozy atmosphere and a reputation for serving up some of the best traditional pies in town, Roselli’s Pizza is the go-to spot for fans of classic Italian-style pizza.

Their hand-tossed crust and rich, flavorful sauces pair perfectly with fresh toppings, making it easy to see why locals keep coming back for more. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or a unique specialty pie, Roselli’s delivers every time.

Roselli's is one of the best pizza parlors in Carmel, IN, for people who love Chicago-style pizzas.

Location: 4335 West 106th St, Carmel, IN 46032

Contact: 317-228-9090

Website: https://www.rosellispizzeria.com/

Order Online: https://ccp.mobileappsuite.com/mobile/businesses/1492/

Hours:

  • Monday to Thursday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
  • Friday 10:30 am – 10:00 pm
  • Saturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
  • Sunday 12:00 pm – 9:00 pm

2. Bella Pizzeria

Bella Pizzeria brings authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to Carmel with an emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients. From their delicious wood-fired crust to the perfectly balanced tomato sauce, every bite at Bella is a flavor-packed experience.

It’s the perfect spot for pizza purists who appreciate the art of making a truly excellent pie.

Bella Pizzeria is an authentic place in Carmel, IN, that serves Neapolitan-style pizza.

Location: 14550 Clay Terrace Blvd. Carmel, IN 46032

Contact: +1-317-569-8911

Website: https://www.thebellapizza.com/locations/

Order Online: https://ct.thebellapizza.com/

Hours: Mon-Sun: 11 am to 8 pm

3. Crafter’s Pizza and Drafthouse

Want craft beer with your craft pizza?

Look no further than Crafter’s Pizza and Drafthouse, where pizza lovers can enjoy hand-crafted pizzas topped with locally sourced ingredients and pair them with a rotating selection of craft brews.

The laid-back vibe and creative toppings make this spot a favorite for a casual night out or a gathering with friends.

Crafter's Pizza and Drafthouse in Carmel, IN, is a great place for pizza lovers who love local ingredients on their pizza.

Location: 2430 E 146th Street, Carmel, IN 46033

Contact: 317-798-2056

Website: https://www.craftersdrafthouse.com/

Order Online: https://www.craftersdrafthouse.com/order-online

Schedule:

  • Monday – Thursday: 3 pm – 11 pm
  • Friday – Saturday: 11 am – 12 am
  • Sunday: 11 am – 11 pm

*The kitchen is Open Until 10:00 PM

4. King Dough Pizzas

If you’re a fan of artisan pizza with a twist, King Dough Pizzas is your new pizza kingdom. Known for their creative toppings and delectable sourdough crust, King Dough puts a gourmet spin on pizza with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.

Their unique pies will have you thinking outside the pizza box!

King Dough Pizzas is a new pizza kingdom in Carmel,IN.

Location: 12505 Old Meridian Street, Carmel, IN 46032

Contact: (317)-669-2201

Website: https://carmel.kingdoughpizzas.com/

Order Online: https://direct.chownow.com/order/28500/locations/58495

Hours:

  • Tues-Thursday 5-9 pm
  • Fri-Sat 12 pm-10 pm
  • Sundays 12 pm-9 pm

5. Fat Dan’s Chicago-style Deli

While known for its deli sandwiches, Fat Dan’s in Carmel also serves up a mean slice of Chicago-style deep dish pizza.

For those who prefer a hearty, cheesy, and stuffed pizza experience, Fat Dan’s brings the Windy City’s best right to Carmel.

Grab a fork and knife, because this pie is packed with layers of flavor!

For those who prefer a hearty, cheesy, and stuffed pizza experience, Fat Dan’s brings the Windy City’s best right to Carmel, IN.

Location: 840 W Main St., Carmel, IN 46032

Contact: 317-993-3330

Website: https://www.fatdansdeli.com/carmel

Order Online: https://slicelife.com/restaurants/in/carmel/46032/fat-dan-s-deli/menu?utm_campaign=order_now_button&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=fatdansdelimenu.com

Schedule:

  • Monday 11 AM–9 pm
  • Tuesday 11 AM–9 pm
  • Wednesday 11 AM–9 pm
  • Thursday 11 AM–9 pm
  • Friday 11 AM–10 pm
  • Saturday 11 AM–10 pm
  • Sunday 11 AM–9 pm

6. Queenie’s Pizza

A Carmel favorite for its fun and funky atmosphere, Queenie’s Pizza serves delicious, locally inspired pies that are as fresh as they come.

From their signature queen-sized slices to their perfectly crispy crusts, Queenie’s is a perfect spot for families, friends, or anyone who loves a slice of joy in a laid-back environment.

Queenie’s in Carmel, IN, is a perfect spot for families, friends, or anyone who loves a slice of joy in a laid-back environment.

Location: 351 Monon Blvd Carmel, IN 46032

Contact: 317-843-6250

Website: https://www.queeniespizza.com/

Hours:

  • Mon-Wed: 3 pm – 10 pm
  • Thu: 11 am – 10 pm
  • Fri-Sat: 11 am – 10 pm
  • Sun: 12 pm – 8 pm

Chow Down on Cheesy Slices

Whether you’re indulging in a deep dish, enjoying a crisp, thin-crust masterpiece, or sampling a gourmet creation, these pizza parlors have earned their spots as local favorites.

From family-friendly venues to trendy hotspots with craft beer pairings, Carmel offers something for everyone. So next time you’re in the mood for a delicious slice (or two!), we at Crossroads hope you will check out these top pizza spots in Carmel—you won’t be disappointed!

Crossroads Foundation Repair is dedicated to helping homeowners in Carmel, Indiana keep their home standing on stable ground. Our specialists are ready to swing into action to get your foundation in the right shape.

Call us today for a free inspection.